Political Wrinkles

Political Wrinkles (http://www.politicalwrinkles.com/)
-   Civil Rights & Abortion (http://www.politicalwrinkles.com/civil-rights-abortion/)
-   -   Teen Abortions Surged In Texas After Republicans Defunded Planned Parenthood (http://www.politicalwrinkles.com/civil-rights-abortion/55003-teen-abortions-surged-texas-after-republicans-defunded-planned-parenthood.html)

foundit66 06-04-2018 06:21 PM

Teen Abortions Surged In Texas After Republicans Defunded Planned Parenthood
 
Quote:

Republicans are trying to find a way to defund Planned Parenthood as part of an overall effort to limit abortion in America. But doing so had the opposite effect in Texas, according to a new study based on research from Texas A&M University.

The study, conducted by economics professor Analisa Packham (now at Miami University), shows that in the first three years after Texas Republicans slashed the family planning budget in 2011 and shut down more than 80 women’s health clinics, the abortion rate among teenagers in the state rose 3 percent over what it would have been had the clinics remained open. After cutting Planned Parenthood out of the state’s subsidized women’s health program, then-Gov. Rick Perry (R) said his “goal” was to “ensure abortions are as rare as possible under existing law.” But the move actually interfered with an overall downward trend in abortions in Texas.

“This certainly isn’t the way to have fewer abortions,” said Dr. Diane Horvath-Cosper, an OB-GYN in Maryland and an advocate with Physicians for Reproductive Health. “The abortion rates nationally have decreased and are at a historic low. So for Texans to see an increase in adolescent abortions is really telling ― it seemed to have followed the national trend until these clinics were defunded.”

The greatest rises in abortion rates occurred in rural areas, where access to affordable family planning care was already scarce. In Gregg County, where the local health center lost 60 percent of its family planning funding, the abortion rate increased by 191 percent between 2012 and 2014. The Austin American-Statesman reported that at least five counties in East Texas also saw “considerable increases” in abortions over that two-year period.
https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry...b09b587d63018a

I've said it before that the right employs tactics which are counter-productive with actually reducing abortion rates. This being yet another example...
:shrug

https://www.nbcnews.com/health/healt...report-n858476
https://www.theguardian.com/commenti...hoice-policies

Joe Shoe 06-04-2018 08:00 PM

Re: Teen Abortions Surged In Texas After Republicans Defunded Planned Parenthood
 
https://www.nationalreview.com/corne...isnt-epidemic/

https://www.lifeissues.org/2017/07/t...ort-fake-news/

foundit66 06-05-2018 12:55 AM

Re: Teen Abortions Surged In Texas After Republicans Defunded Planned Parenthood
 
:rolls
It's amusing that both articles make the same errors in ignoring what is plainly stated...
The articles fixate on the rate falling, which is plainly acknowledged in the original article.

The point is that "... the abortion rate among teenagers in the state rose 3 percent over what it would have been had the clinics remained open"
So, for example, if the rate should have decreased by 10% ...
... the actual decrease was only 7%.

Two factors here...
First off, if the defunding of Planned Parenthood were to actually have the desired effect, the rate should have decreased by more than it would have originally. The fact that it didn't should tell people something... :rolls

Second, this isn't the first study to note the negative correlation between reduced abortion access and increase in abortion.
And as I pointed out with the follow-on articles, Packham's article was not the first one to note this relationship. :thumbsup

Abortion rates go down when countries make it legal: report
Want to lower the abortion rate? Support pro-choice policies

jimbo 06-05-2018 08:52 AM

Re: Teen Abortions Surged In Texas After Republicans Defunded Planned Parenthood
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by foundit66 (Post 935946)
:rolls
It's amusing that both articles make the same errors in ignoring what is plainly stated...
The articles fixate on the rate falling, which is plainly acknowledged in the original article.

The point is that "... the abortion rate among teenagers in the state rose 3 percent over what it would have been had the clinics remained open"
So, for example, if the rate should have decreased by 10% ...
... the actual decrease was only 7%.

Two factors here...
First off, if the defunding of Planned Parenthood were to actually have the desired effect, the rate should have decreased by more than it would have originally. The fact that it didn't should tell people something... :rolls

Second, this isn't the first study to note the negative correlation between reduced abortion access and increase in abortion.
And as I pointed out with the follow-on articles, Packham's article was not the first one to note this relationship. :thumbsup

Abortion rates go down when countries make it legal: report
Want to lower the abortion rate? Support pro-choice policies

If teen abortions rose after they cost more, then there is something else going on. Anybody know what something else is?

FrancSevin 06-05-2018 08:59 AM

Re: Teen Abortions Surged In Texas After Republicans Defunded Planned Parenthood
 
A "correlation" and a connected "causation" are not the same thing.

And a 3% rise or fall of an unqualified raw statistic is hardly noteworthy.

Jus' sayin'

foundit66 06-05-2018 10:51 AM

Re: Teen Abortions Surged In Texas After Republicans Defunded Planned Parenthood
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by FrancSevin (Post 935969)
A "correlation" and a connected "causation" are not the same thing.
And a 3% rise or fall of an unqualified raw statistic is hardly noteworthy.
Jus' sayin'

When the same behavior is seen in multiple scenarios / different countries, it's not something to be ignored.

Unless you're a right-winger who prizes the method over the actual goal. In which case the rise in abortions fuels a faux sense of superiority which is just as fine as decreasing abortions... :rolls


Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbo
If teen abortions rose after they cost more, then there is something else going on. Anybody know what something else is?

:rolls

I've posted this type of stuff numerous times before.
Access to free birth control reduces abortion rates
The right fixates on abortions but ignores all the other stuff that Planned Parenthood does.

GetAClue 06-05-2018 11:45 AM

Re: Teen Abortions Surged In Texas After Republicans Defunded Planned Parenthood
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by foundit66 (Post 935988)
When the same behavior is seen in multiple scenarios / different countries, it's not something to be ignored.

Unless you're a right-winger who prizes the method over the actual goal. In which case the rise in abortions fuels a faux sense of superiority which is just as fine as decreasing abortions... :rolls



:rolls

I've posted this type of stuff numerous times before.
Access to free birth control reduces abortion rates
The right fixates on abortions but ignores all the other stuff that Planned Parenthood does.

That's like saying ignore that 6 million Jews that Hitler killed and look at the good things he did like building the Autoban.

jimbo 06-05-2018 12:06 PM

Re: Teen Abortions Surged In Texas After Republicans Defunded Planned Parenthood
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by foundit66 (Post 935988)
When the same behavior is seen in multiple scenarios / different countries, it's not something to be ignored.

Unless you're a right-winger who prizes the method over the actual goal. In which case the rise in abortions fuels a faux sense of superiority which is just as fine as decreasing abortions... :rolls



:rolls

I've posted this type of stuff numerous times before.
Access to free birth control reduces abortion rates
The right fixates on abortions but ignores all the other stuff that Planned Parenthood does.

Access to other people pay birth control is not the issue. Abortion is.

If PP wants government money, and it's very arguable whether they should get it at all, then PP should play by the keeper of the purse's rules. If not, no money.

FrancSevin 06-05-2018 12:50 PM

Re: Teen Abortions Surged In Texas After Republicans Defunded Planned Parenthood
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by foundit66 (Post 935988)
When the same behavior is seen in multiple scenarios / different countries, it's not something to be ignored.

Unless you're a right-winger who prizes the method over the actual goal. In which case the rise in abortions fuels a faux sense of superiority which is just as fine as decreasing abortions... :rolls



:rolls

I've posted this type of stuff numerous times before.
Access to free birth control reduces abortion rates
The right fixates on abortions but ignores all the other stuff that Planned Parenthood does.

Why do you insist on making the respect for life a partisan issue. Or a religious one. It is a human issue.
I'm a right winger who prizes life. And who holds himself and others responsible for the results of their actions. But never at the cost of an innocent.

foundit66 06-05-2018 08:06 PM

Re: Teen Abortions Surged In Texas After Republicans Defunded Planned Parenthood
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GetAClue (Post 935993)
That's like saying ignore that 6 million Jews that Hitler killed and look at the good things he did like building the Autoban.

No. It's nothing like that.
It's about fighting smarter. Not fighting "harder".
It's about implementing a successful method to lower abortion as opposed to implementing a method you want to lower abortion but actually doesn't have that effect.


Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbo (Post 935995)
Access to other people pay birth control is not the issue. Abortion is.

I thought you wanted an answer to your question.
You suspected something else must be going on. I answered that question.

And if you refuse to recognize that readily accessible birth control does impact abortion rates, then that's on you... :rolls


Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbo (Post 935995)
If PP wants government money, and it's very arguable whether they should get it at all, then PP should play by the keeper of the purse's rules. If not, no money.

They are playing by the rules. :rolls


Quote:

Originally Posted by FrancSevin (Post 936000)
Why do you insist on making the respect for life a partisan issue. Or a religious one. It is a human issue.
I'm a right winger who prizes life. And who holds himself and others responsible for the results of their actions. But never at the cost of an innocent.

If you think I am the one making it a partisan issue, then there is nothing more that can be really said to you... :rolls

But if you prize life and if you consider abortion to be violating that, wouldn't you want to go with a policy that has demonstrated capability to lower abortion rates?
i.e. making sure birth control is readily accessible and affordable and/or free?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:06 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.


Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.2.0