View Single Post
  #380 (permalink)  
Old 11-11-2011, 10:18 PM
Joe Shoe's Avatar
Joe Shoe Joe Shoe is offline
PW Enlightenment
 
Join Date: Nov 2011
Posts: 5,218
Thanks: 822
Thanked 1,589 Times in 1,079 Posts
Default Re: The Dumbest Argument Against Gay Marriage...

Quote:
Originally Posted by talloulou View Post
Does the US military treat women and men equally? No. Are they bound by the constitution to treat them equally. No.

The 14th amendment may be used to prohibit some forms of gender discrimination but it does not make gender discrimination constitutionally illegal the way an ERA would.
Good point.
It has become a fad of some folks to view the 14th Amendment as a 'blank check' sort of Amendment, by trying to make anything fit under the equal protection clause. So broad is such an approach that anything--literally any interpretation by which one claims some 'right'--could be spun as justified. It's almost as if the 14th has come to be considered by some a sort of constitution in and of itself (by 'priders, at least). No NEED for the rest, when one takes that sort of all-encompassing view of the 14th! To make the 14th fit gay marriage, it could be argued for anything, pretty much. It's the closest thing they've remotely been able to find to a gay-marriage amendment, and the fact they've had to co-opt a racism amendment in order to do that is pretty telling. To use the 14th in such a flippant, blank-check sort of way judicially is VERY dangerous precedent.
Quote:
"Activist federal judges, on the other hand, see the 14th Amendment as a blank check to legalize whatever conduct they happen to approve of, such as abortion, homosexuality, & gay marriage." - Judicial Abuse of the Fourteenth Amendment: Abortion, Sexual Orientation & Gay Marriage Publius-Huldah's Blog
Reply With Quote